Skip to main content

Demise of the Neighbourhood

Lingering Questions

The dismantling of the neighbourhood left unanswered questions and lingering feelings in the minds and hearts of many Brightsiders, especially about issues of social justice and environmental injustice. What happened to their homes and community? Many Brightsiders today cry out - hear our voice!   

 

Some of the Brightsiders who lived through the 1946 Stelco Strike suspected that their neighbourhood was demolished in retaliation for the role it played in that long, bitter labour dispute. The dismantling of Woodlands Park in 1947 has long been seen as a reaction to the park’s role as a space of labour organizing and protest. Could similar motivations have informed the demolition of Brightside?

Listen: Why Did It Happen. Click the play circle below.

Show/Hide Transcript

Speaker 1:    

There’s a lot of politics. 

Speaker 2:    

Yeah yeah. 

Speaker 1:    

A lot of politics. 

Because of the strike and 46. Okay. 

We went on strike and there’s a lot of politics involved to get rid of Brightside. I believe that so do most of the older guys. 

Listen: Another View. Click the play circle below.

Show/Hide Transcript

Speaker 1:    

One theory in terms of like why the neighbourhood was maybe, um, dismantled, that your brother, ah, actually, that Ernie advanced last month, was they were just fed up with people going on strike and Brightside was a hotbed, and it all goes back to the ’46 moment. 

But, do you think there’s anything to that? He says that that’s what an older generation kind of felt. 

Speaker 2:    

I, I don’t think so. 

I think it was booming. And there were no parking. The employees had to pay to park. 

We had an empty lot right across behind Johnny’s house. And they charged, whoever owned that, and they charged people to park there. 

And other, um, like Andreatta’s business, if you wanted to park there, and the Yachetti business,  you had to pay. 

Now most of them you say had a good size parking lot, but it wasn’t enough. 

And then they changed to Gage and those streets to one way. 

So, these, these guys all raced up our street. Going south. And they needed parking. They needed parking spot. 

Speaker 3:    

But was that the reason why the destruction.  

Speaker 2:    

I think so. 

Speaker 3:    

Well. 

Speaker 1:    

That they what. 

Speaker 2:    

That they expropriated; that they needed the land. 

For parking. 

Yeah. 

 

Listen: Feelings About Losing Brightside. Click the play circle below.

Show/Hide Transcript

Speaker 1:    

Were the memories of Brightside always tainted by the… 

Speaker 2:    

Bad things.  

Speaker 1:    

…having left or were there happy memories? 

Speaker 3:    

My mother didn’t resent leaving but she did resent how the city, or whoever, did it to her because she hadn’t sold their house. She had moved out of there but they rented the house. 

Speaker 1:    

Okay. 

Speaker 3:    

But she resented the fact that they came down hard on her and she had no choice 

Speaker 4:    

Yep. 

Speaker 3:    

And price wise or anything like that you know there was no question, ‘that’s what you’re going to get and you’re going to leave. And that’s it.’ 

Speaker 4:    

That’s it. 

Speaker 1:    

Yeah. 

Speaker 4:    

‘Take it or leave it.’ 

Speaker 1:    

Yeah.  

And that’s the only thing that really bothered her. 

Yeah. 

Speaker 5:    

Tell her about the relief. 

Speaker 6:    

I don’t know, I think my father was a little different. I seem to remember, but I am not too sure about him holding out… 

Speaker 7:    

Well, there was a difference Vince between someone acquiring your house through purchase then someone acquiring your house through expropriation. You guys were on a different tract. 

Speaker 6:    

Yeah. 

No fault to you Ern.. 

No. No. 

Speaker 7:    

But it just… So you know it was just a little different. 

Speaker 2:    

No no. 

Speaker 3:    

Yeah, he loved his home. He built that home there. 

Yeah sure. 

He …  it to, I don’t know if it was Stelco or the city, and then he built his own home, right on the corner. 

 

Listen: Ought Never To Have Been There. Click the play circle below.

Show/Hide Transcript

Speaker 1:    

I haven’t found any evidence that this was happening in Brightside. 

Speaker 1=2:    

The hidden stuff. 

Speaker 1:    

And I think that much of it has to do with the notion that, and you can see it in that document that he has got, the sense that this is a community that ‘ought not to be there.’  

You know, how Flatt ever got - and you had said this some time ago - how he got that land developed in that Survey No. 453, um, is kind of a mystery.  

But it’s interesting… 

Let's stay connected!

There are three ways to reach Hamilton Civic Museums

1. Sign up for “The Linc”, the Hamilton Civic Museums newsletter, to learn more about upcoming programs and events.

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: City of Hamilton - Hamilton Civic Museums, 28 James Street North, 2nd Floor, Hamilton L8R 2K1, CA, http://www.hamilton.ca/museums. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the Unsubscribe link, found at the bottom of every email.

2. Follow us on Social Media.

3. Share a story of Hamilton’s history.

Contact Us
crossmenuchevron-downchevron-left